Reviving the ‘Kerala Model’ of development
- Kerala has long been recognised to have done many things right.
- The ‘Kerala Model’ seemed to show impressive levels of human development indicators in health, education and quality of life, comparable even to some rich countries.
- It could be achieved without a correspondingly high level of income.
Some Questions arising
- What is the solution for exporting our unemployment and becoming over-dependent on remittances?
- Can we build high growth and strong human development indicators on such a flimsy basis?
- Is it sustainable?
A focus on ‘failures’
- The Kerala model is now under threat from emerging social and environmental risks.
- Some of the very strengths of Kerala’s approach have become sources of vulnerability.
- In the face of rising risks, the Kerala model needs to be revitalised.
- Kerala has India’s highest literacy rate despite ranking only the ninth-highest in per capita income among 28 States.
- As new global risks emerge in areas from health to climate change, Kerala’s policies need to be bolstered and new challenges deftly managed.
- Severely hit by COVID-19, Kerala’s Gross State Domestic Product (GSDP) contracted over 2019-20 and 2021-22, and unemployment at 9% is much higher than the 6% national average.
- The space to revive Kerala’s sagging economy is limited because of a high fiscal deficit, around 4% of GSDP.
- These difficulties could be mitigated by smarter socio-economic investments, attention to good governance and a far better stewardship of the environment.
- Kerala can develop as a knowledge economy, improve the quality of higher education and vocational training to meet the requirements of a modern workforce.
- Also it can build on successes in tourism and hospitality services.
Interventions that reach all
- The focus should be on the quantity as well as quality of health and education and ensuring that interventions reach all segments of the population.
- Basic education should continue to be a priority but it is higher education that presents a pivotal opportunity on the global stage for Kerala.
- Kerala could become a regional centre for tertiary education in areas such as marine biology, health care and digital technology, where it has considerable expertise.
- Digital tools are being widely used in Kerala’s COVID-19 response for example, application of India’s eSanjeevani-a telemedicine portal, offering psychosocial support for those struggling with the virus or its after-effects.
- Such approaches can build on and expand in learnings, for instance from Singapore’s new generation of health apps and technologies.
Cracks in the health system
- Serious gaps are growing in Kerala’s health system.
- A pandemic response that laid a stress on mask-wearing and social distancing and tracing got off to a vigorous early start.
- Infections and deaths skyrocketed in 2021, partly as the population is highly mobile and also because Kerala let its guard down in key areas of surveillance.
- Testing has been widespread which helped reveal infections more transparently.
- Sustaining the edge on health care should be high on the policy agenda.
- Another strength that needs to be sustained involves institutions, building on the State’s grassroots organisation, participatory governance and a free press.
- The Public Affairs Index 2020 ranked Kerala as the best-governed large State in 2019 on the basis of 50 indicators reflecting equity, growth and sustainability.
- Decentralised governance - a strong grass-roots-level network of Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHA), volunteer groups and Kudumbashree members helped in pandemic management.
- But Kerala needs to be more agile in public expenditure on health and developing local self delivery systems.
The Earth does matter
- An asset that turned into a worrying flash point is the State’s rich but fragile ecology that requires heightened protection.
- Decades of ecological degradation amplified the impact of the 2018 floods in Kerala that took some 483 lives, displaced 14.5 lakh people, and cost over 40,000 crore.
- It is vital that the Madhav Gadgil Committee report is adopted with the minimal necessary modifications to protect vulnerable populations.
- The ecological disaster across the Western Ghats needs to be confronted and investments made to repair forests, river systems, water bodies, and flood plains.
- The State needs a bold programme of forest restoration in keeping with the commitments on forest protection from over 130 nations at COP26.
- Kerala urgently needs to revive its network of rivers, their tributaries and streams.
- Sand Mining needs to be stopped until the sandy riverbeds are restored.
- Water management - by periodic release of water from the dams, as indicated by the World Commission on Dams.
- This with desilting of dams could control the quantity of run-off into the dams and the need for sudden releases that exacerbate floods.
- Kerala’s supply of fresh water is being jeopardised by inadequate facilities for water containment.
- Water quality and people’s health - hurt by domestic waste and industrial effluents, calling for better water treatment.
Moment for Change
- A reinvigorated Kerala model will do well to recognise the symbiotic links among social outcomes, environmental management and participatory governance and take actions that cut across these areas.
- It is time for revival. Need to open mental horizons to the world, outgrow our shopworn ideologies and create investment and business-friendly conditions for sustainable development.
- One prerequisite for achieving sustainable development would be to change the perceptions of the State in our extremely politicised environment.
- Political parties can differ on the precise policies and investments needed, but they must come together on a platform that transcends their differences.
- Sree Narayana Guru famously said, “matham ethayalum, manushyan nannayalmathi - whatever his religion, it is enough that a man be good.”
- Similarly “rashtriyam ethayalum, rashtram nannayalmathi - whatever the politics, it is enough that the country be better.”