The Competition (Amendment) Bill, 2022
- The long-awaited Bill to amend the Competition Act, 2002, was finally tabled in the Lok Sabha recently.
Background
- The Indian Competition Act was passed in 2002
- But it came into effect only seven years later.
- Provided for the establishment of the Competition Commission
- Pursues 3 issues of anti-competitive practices:
- anti-competitive agreements
- abuse of dominance
- combinations.
- Market changed rapidly due to technological changes, amendments became necessary to promote market competition.
- So, a review committee was established in 2019.
New Changes in dealing with new-age market combinations
- Section 5: Parties indulging in merger, acquisition, or amalgamation need to notify the Commission of the combination on the basis of ‘asset’ or ‘turnover’.
- New Bill proposes to add a ‘deal value’ threshold.
- Mandatory to notify the Commission of any transaction with a deal value over ₹2,000 crore or if either of the parties has ‘substantial business operations in India’.
- Commission shall frame regulations to prescribe the requirements for assessing whether an enterprise has ‘substantial business operations in India’.
- It will strengthen the Commission’s review mechanism
- Particularly in digital & infrastructure, not reported earlier, as the asset or turnover values did not meet jurisdictional thresholds.
- When business entities are willing to execute a combination, they must inform the Commission.
- Commission may approve or disapprove the combination.
- Earlier had 210 days to approve the combination, after which it was automatically approved.
- New Bill seeks to accelerate the timeline to only 150 working days (a 30 days conservatory period for extensions).
- Will speed up the clearance of combinations
- Will increase the importance of pre-filing consultations with the Commission.
Challenges faced by combining parties
Unaffordable Transactions | Acquisitions involving open market purchase of target shares must be completed quickly. If parties wait for the Commission’s clearance, the transaction may become unaffordable. |
Unfavourable regulations | Similar to the European Union merger regulations. Amendment Bill proposes to exempt open market purchases & stock market transactions to advance notify them to Commission. Condition: acquirer does not exercise voting or ownership rights until the transaction is approved and notified to the Commission. |
Hub-and-Spoke Cartels
- Currently, the prohibition on anti-competitive agreements covers entities with similar trades engaging in anti- competitive practices.
- It ignores hub-and-spoke cartels operating at different levels of vertical chain by distributors and suppliers.
- The amendment broadens the scope of ‘anti-competitive agreements’ to catch entities facilitating cartelisation.
'Settlements' and 'commitments' mechanisms
- The new amendment proposes a framework for settlements and commitments relating to vertical agreements and abuse of dominance.
- In this case, the parties may apply for a ‘commitment’ before the Director General (DG) submits the report.
- ‘Settlement’ will be considered after the report is submitted and before the Commission decides.
- In the amendment, the Commission's decision will not be appealable after hearing all stakeholders in the case.
- It will come out with regulations regarding procedural aspects.
‘Leniency Plus’ Provision
- Allows the commission to give an additional waiver of penalties to an applicant who discloses the existence of another cartel in an unrelated market.
- Condition: The information enables the Commission to form a prima facie opinion about the existence of the cartel.
Appointment of the DG by the Commission rather than the Central government
- According to the Bill, the DG has the power to conduct investigations, including raids.
- The Commission will only consider information filed within three years of the occurrence of the cause of action.
- For false information filed, five crore penalty will be imposed.
- For failure to comply with the Commission directions, a penalty of ₹10 crore will be imposed.
- Commission will develop guidelines regarding the amount of penalties for various competition violations.
- For an appeal to be heard by the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) against the Commission’s order, the party will have to deposit 25% of the penalty amount.
Way forward
- By these amendments, the Commission should be better equipped to handle new-age market and transform its functioning to be more robust.
- The proposed amendments are heavily dependent on regulations that will be notified by the Commission later.
- These regulations will influence the proposals.
- The government needs to recognise that market dynamics change constantly, so it is necessary to update laws regularly.